Heretic (2024): A24’s Psychological Horror with Hugh Grant in a Chilling Role
Heretic (2024), produced by A24, delivers a gripping blend of psychological horror and religious tension. Directors Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, known for A Quiet Place, return with a slower but far more cerebral thriller. The film stars Hugh Grant, Sophie Thatcher, and Chloe East, each giving intense performances that keep audiences on edge.
Plot Summary: A Mission Turns Into a Trap
The story follows two young Mormon missionaries—Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East). As part of their mission, they knock on doors in a quiet American suburb, hoping to share their faith. One day, they meet Mr. Reed (Hugh Grant), a charming older man who invites them inside.
However, the encounter quickly spirals into a nightmare. Mr. Reed reveals a darker agenda. He traps the women and forces them into a twisted psychological game. As tension builds, both missionaries must fight for their survival—mentally and physically.
Strong Performances Drive the Film
Hugh Grant surprises audiences with his unsettling portrayal of Mr. Reed. Far from his usual romantic roles, he delivers cold, manipulative energy that holds your attention. Meanwhile, Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East show impressive emotional range. Their characters shift from confident missionaries to terrified survivors, making the story feel personal and urgent.
Direction and Atmosphere
Beck and Woods create a slow-burning, suspenseful atmosphere. They use minimal music and tight cinematography to heighten the sense of isolation. Every frame feels intentional, and the house itself becomes a character—claustrophobic, shadowy, and full of menace.
Although the film avoids traditional jump scares, it uses silence, pacing, and dialogue to build dread. This choice gives Heretic a more mature and unsettling tone compared to typical horror releases.
Critical Response and Awards
Heretic premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival on September 8, 2024, and hit U.S. theaters on November 8, 2024. Critics praised the film’s tension and Grant’s performance. As a result, he received nominations from the Golden Globes, BAFTA, and Critics’ Choice Awards for Best Actor.
The film scored a 91% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with reviewers highlighting its intelligent script and haunting execution.
Box Office and Streaming
On a modest $10 million budget, Heretic earned $59 million globally, including $11 million in its opening weekend. Its strong word-of-mouth helped sustain box office success. Since December 10, 2024, digital platforms like Apple TV and Google Play offer the film for rent or purchase. It’s also scheduled to stream on Max (HBO Max) by March 2025.
Final Verdict: A Must-Watch for Horror Fans
If you enjoy psychological horror that challenges your mind, Heretic deserves your attention. It’s not just scary—it’s thought-provoking. With standout performances, clever direction, and a chilling message about belief and control, this A24 gem ranks among the most memorable horror films of 2024.
